Licence Audit
Audit of the OpenSimulator 0.9.3.0 C# source tree and its dependencies,
performed 2026-11-13 against the C# reference tree
(opensim-0.9.3.0-source).
Project licence: LGPL-3.0-or-later.
Executive summary
Welkin is a clean-room Rust port of OpenSimulator, licensed LGPL-3.0-or-later. This audit examined every third-party library, binary, and data file shipped in the C# source tree to determine what can be reused, what must be replaced, and what licence obligations apply.
Key findings:
- All C# third-party dependencies are dropped. The Rust port replaces every C# library with a Rust equivalent. No Ms-PL, MPL-1.1, or custom-licensed code carries forward.
- Aurora Viewer crates are GPL-3.0-or-later, compatible with the project licence. They transitively bring in openjpeg-sys (BSD-2-Clause), V-HACD (BSD-3-Clause), and parry3d (Apache-2.0) -- all compatible.
- The SL message template is LGPL-2.1 (Linden Lab), which is GPLv3-compatible. It lives in the aurora-msg crate, not in this repo.
- No default asset library is shipped. The C# tree's assets have mixed provenance (CC-BY-SA 3.0, unknown, CC-BY-NC). The server starts without them.
- All Rust dependency licences are GPLv3-compatible. The dependency tree uses MIT, Apache-2.0, BSD-2/3-Clause, ISC, Zlib, Unicode-3.0, CDLA-Permissive-2.0, BSL-1.0, CC0-1.0, and Unlicense -- all compatible with LGPL-3.0-or-later.
- Three items were flagged as GPL-incompatible in the C# tree (Ms-PL libraries, CC-BY-SA 3.0 artwork, Warp3D). All are dropped.
Disposition summary: of 76+ third-party items in the C# tree, zero
are carried into the Rust port. The only external code comes from
crates.io dependencies and Aurora Viewer git dependencies, all with
confirmed-compatible licences. A deny.toml enforces the allow-list
via cargo deny.
Decisions
- D1 (2026-11-15): LGPL-3.0-or-later, so that Aurora Viewer's crates can be reused. Ported OpenSimulator code keeps its BSD-3-Clause notice.
- D2 (2026-11-13): Repository name
welkin, local development only.
OpenSimulator source
BSD-3-Clause (LICENSE.txt, CONTRIBUTORS.txt). All ported code retains the notice. GPLv3 permits including BSD-3-Clause code.
Aurora Viewer crates
| Crate | Licence | Disposition |
|---|---|---|
| aurora-llsd | GPL-3.0-or-later | Pinned git dep, wrapped |
| aurora-msg | GPL-3.0-or-later (message template: LGPL 2.1 from Linden Lab) | Pinned git dep, wrapped |
| aurora-prim | GPL-3.0-or-later (code derived from SL viewer, originally LGPL 2.1) | Pinned git dep, wrapped |
| aurora-assets | GPL-3.0-or-later; bundles openjpeg-sys (BSD-2), V-HACD (BSD-3), parry3d (Apache-2.0) | Pinned git dep, wrapped |
| aurora-net | GPL-3.0-or-later | Test bot only, not in server |
Pinned at commit 3d523b14a17bbc6484b208378c0eef291ad5ac32.
Aurora name and logo are trademarks -- not used.
2.1 ThirdPartyLicenses/ and bin/ -- full inventory
ThirdPartyLicenses/ files
| File | Library | Licence | Disposition for Rust port |
|---|---|---|---|
| Aurora-Sim.txt | Aurora Sim (precursor) | BSD-3-Clause | Historical reference only; not used |
| BclExtras.txt | BclExtras | Ms-PL | Dropped (Ms-PL is GPL-incompatible) |
| Bullet for Xna (ModifiedBulletX).txt | BulletX .NET port | zlib | Dropped; replaced by Rapier |
| Bullet-XNA.txt | Bullet-XNA C#/XNA port | zlib | Dropped; replaced by Rapier |
| BulletLicense.txt | Bullet Physics | zlib | Dropped; replaced by Rapier |
| C# Webserver.txt | Gauffin HttpServer | Apache-2.0 | Dropped; replaced by axum |
| C5.txt | C5 Generic Collections | MIT | Dropped; std collections |
| CircularBuffer.txt | CircularBuffer | BSD-3-Clause | Dropped; not needed |
| ConvexDecompositionDotNet.txt | ConvexDecompositionDotNet | MIT | Dropped; V-HACD in parry3d |
| CSCompilerTools.txt | Compiler Tools (Malcolm Crowe) | "Used with permission" (not OSS) | Dropped; not an open-source licence |
| CSJ2K.txt | CSJ2K (JJ2000 C# port) | Custom JJ2000 notice (field-of-use clause) | Dropped; replaced by openjpeg-sys |
| DefaultTerrain.txt | SL viewer default terrain | CC-BY-SA 3.0 (Linden Lab) | Not GPLv3-compatible; do not include; generate new terrain |
| DotNetOpenid.txt | DotNetOpenId | BSD-3-Clause | Dropped; openidconnect crate |
| DotNetZip.txt | DotNetZip | Ms-PL | Dropped (Ms-PL is GPL-incompatible) |
| DotNetZip-bzip2.txt | DotNetZip bzip2 | Apache-2.0 (from Apache commons) | Dropped; flate2/bzip2 crate |
| DotNetZip-zlib.txt | DotNetZip zlib | Ms-PL + MKL | Dropped (Ms-PL is GPL-incompatible) |
| GoogleProtoBuffer.txt | protobuf-csharp-port | BSD-3-Clause (Google) | Dropped; not needed |
| GTCache.txt | GlynnTucker.Cache | GPL/MPL-1.1 dual | Dropped (MPL-1.1 alone is GPL-incompatible) |
| ICSharpCode.SharpZipLib.license.txt | SharpZipLib | GPL-2.0+ with linking exception | Dropped; flate2/zip crate |
| libsl.txt | libsecondlife / OpenMetaverse | BSD-3-Clause | Replaced by Aurora crates + new code |
| log4net | log4net | Apache-2.0 | Dropped; tracing crate |
| MonoAddins.txt | Mono.Addins | MIT | Dropped; not needed |
| Mono.Xna (MonoXnaCompactMaths).txt | MonoXna compact maths | MIT | Dropped; glam crate |
| MXP.txt | Metaverse Exchange Protocol | Apache-2.0 | Dropped; not implemented |
| MySQL.txt | MySQL Connector/NET | GPLv2 + FLOSS exception | Dropped; sqlx crate |
| Nini.txt | Nini (INI parser) | MIT | Dropped; toml + configparser crate |
| Npgsql.txt | Npgsql (PostgreSQL driver) | PostgreSQL licence (permissive) | Dropped; sqlx crate |
| ODE.txt | Open Dynamics Engine | BSD-3-Clause | Dropped; Rapier crate |
| OpenJpeg.txt | OpenJPEG | BSD-2-Clause | Via openjpeg-sys in aurora-assets |
| Protobuf-net.txt | protobuf-net | BSD (via Google protobuf) | Dropped; not needed |
| Prototype.txt | Prototype.js | MIT | Dropped; not applicable to server |
| SmartThreadPool.txt | SmartThreadPool | Ms-PL | Dropped (Ms-PL is GPL-incompatible) |
| XML-RPC.NET.txt | XML-RPC.NET | MIT (X11) | Dropped; custom Rust implementation |
bin/ DLLs -- full inventory
| DLL | Library | Licence | Disposition |
|---|---|---|---|
| BouncyCastle.Cryptography.dll | BouncyCastle | MIT | Dropped; rustls + ring |
| BulletXNA.dll | Bullet XNA C# port | zlib | Dropped; Rapier |
| C5.dll | C5 Generic Collections | MIT | Dropped; std collections |
| CSJ2K.dll | CSJ2K JPEG 2000 | Custom JJ2000 | Dropped; openjpeg-sys |
| DotNetOpenId.dll | DotNetOpenId | BSD-3-Clause | Dropped; openidconnect crate |
| ICSharpCode.SharpZipLib.dll | SharpZipLib | GPL-2.0+ with linking exception | Dropped; flate2 |
| Ionic.Zip.dll | DotNetZip | Ms-PL | Dropped |
| libzstd.dll | Zstandard native | BSD-3-Clause (Facebook) | Dropped; zstd crate if needed |
| log4net.dll | log4net | Apache-2.0 | Dropped; tracing |
| LukeSkywalker.IPNetwork.dll | IPNetwork | Apache-2.0 | Dropped; std::net / ipnetwork crate |
| MailKit.dll | MailKit | MIT | Dropped; lettre crate |
| mautil.exe | Mono.Addins utility | MIT (part of Mono.Addins) | Dropped; not needed |
| Microsoft.Extensions.Logging.Abstractions.dll | .NET runtime | MIT (Microsoft) | Dropped; tracing |
| MimeKit.dll | MimeKit | MIT | Dropped; lettre crate |
| Mono.Addins.CecilReflector.dll | Mono.Addins | MIT | Dropped; not needed |
| Mono.Addins.dll | Mono.Addins | MIT | Dropped; not needed |
| Mono.Addins.Setup.dll | Mono.Addins | MIT | Dropped; not needed |
| Mono.Cecil.dll | Mono.Cecil | MIT | Dropped; not needed |
| Mono.Data.Sqlite.dll | Mono SQLite binding | MIT | Dropped; sqlx |
| Mono.Data.SqliteClient.dll | Mono SQLite legacy client | MIT | Dropped; sqlx |
| Mono.Security.dll | Mono.Security | MIT | Dropped; rustls |
| MySql.Data.dll | MySQL Connector/NET | GPLv2 + FLOSS exception | Dropped; sqlx |
| NDesk.Options.dll | NDesk.Options | MIT | Dropped; clap crate |
| netcd.dll | etcd client | Unknown (no licence file in tree) | Dropped; not needed |
| Newtonsoft.Json.dll | Json.NET | MIT | Dropped; serde_json |
| Nini.dll | Nini | MIT | Dropped; configparser |
| Npgsql.dll | Npgsql | PostgreSQL licence (permissive) | Dropped; sqlx |
| nunit.framework.dll | NUnit | MIT | Dropped; Rust built-in tests |
| OpenMetaverse.dll | OpenMetaverse (libomv) | BSD-3-Clause | Replaced by Aurora crates |
| OpenMetaverse.Rendering.Meshmerizer.dll | OpenMetaverse Meshmerizer | BSD-3-Clause | Replaced by welkin-prim |
| OpenMetaverse.StructuredData.dll | OpenMetaverse LLSD | BSD-3-Clause | Replaced by aurora-llsd |
| OpenMetaverseTypes.dll | OpenMetaverse types | BSD-3-Clause | Replaced by welkin-types |
| prebuild.dll | Prebuild build tool | BSD-3-Clause | Dropped; Cargo replaces it |
| PrimMesher.dll | PrimMesher | BSD-3-Clause (OpenSim contributor) | Replaced by welkin-prim |
| RestSharp.dll | RestSharp | Apache-2.0 | Dropped; reqwest crate |
| System.Configuration.ConfigurationManager.dll | .NET runtime | MIT (Microsoft) | Dropped; not needed |
| System.Drawing.Common.dll.linux/win | .NET runtime | MIT (Microsoft) | Dropped; image crate if needed |
| System.Runtime.Caching.dll | .NET runtime | MIT (Microsoft) | Dropped; not needed |
| System.Security.Permissions.dll | .NET runtime | MIT (Microsoft) | Dropped; not needed |
| Tools.dll | OpenSim build tools | BSD-3-Clause (OpenSim) | Dropped; Cargo replaces it |
| Warp3D.dll | Warp3D software renderer | UNKNOWN -- see 2.4 | Not needed for server |
| XMLRPC.dll | XML-RPC.NET | MIT | Dropped; custom implementation |
| zlib.net.dll | zlib.net managed zlib | zlib/libpng | Dropped; flate2 |
| ZstdNet.dll | ZstdNet (.NET wrapper) | BSD-3-Clause | Dropped; zstd crate if needed |
bin/lib64/ native libraries
| File | Library | Licence | Disposition |
|---|---|---|---|
| BulletSim-*.dll/.so/.dylib | BulletSim native | zlib (Bullet Physics) | Dropped; Rapier |
| libBulletSim*.so/.dylib | BulletSim native | zlib (Bullet Physics) | Dropped; Rapier |
| libopenjpeg-dotnet*.so/.dll/.dylib | OpenJPEG .NET wrapper | BSD-2-Clause | Via openjpeg-sys in aurora-assets |
| libsqlite3*.so/.dylib, sqlite3.dll | SQLite | Public domain | Via sqlx + system sqlite |
| libubode*.so/.dylib, ubode.dll | ubODE (modified ODE) | BSD-3-Clause / LGPL-2.1 dual | Dropped; Rapier |
bin/ non-binary files of note
| File | What | Licence | Disposition |
|---|---|---|---|
| avatar-texture.dat | Avatar texture UUID map | Unclear; OpenSim data | Investigate if needed |
| defaultstripe.png | Default texture | Unclear | Generate new if needed |
| ScriptSyntax.xml | LSL function signatures | BSD-3-Clause (OpenSim) | May port for script compiler |
| OpenSimDefaults.ini | Default configuration | BSD-3-Clause (OpenSim) | Reference; rewrite in TOML |
| excuses | Humour file | N/A | Not needed |
2.2 Protocol message template licence
The message template file (message_template.msg) defines the Second Life
UDP protocol messages. It is found at:
aurora-msg crate: crates/aurora-msg/message_template.msg
Header text: "Linden Lab development message templates", version 2.0.
No explicit licence statement appears in the file itself.
Origin: This file originates from the Second Life viewer source code, which Linden Lab released under LGPL 2.1 (GNU Lesser General Public License version 2.1). The file has been maintained by the viewer community and updated for protocol extensions.
Licence determination:
- The SL viewer source (including indra/llmessage/ and the template) was released under LGPL 2.1 by Linden Lab.
- LGPL 2.1 is GPLv3-compatible (FSF confirmed: LGPL 2.1 code can be included in an LGPL-3.0-or-later project).
- Aurora-msg's build.rs generates Rust structs from this template at compile time. The generated code is a derivative work of the template.
- Status: CLEAR. LGPL 2.1 -> GPL-3.0-or-later is permitted.
Note: The template is not shipped in Welkin directly. It lives in the aurora-msg crate (pinned git dependency) and is consumed via build.rs code generation. No .msg file is distributed with Welkin binaries.
2.3 bin/openmetaverse_data/ and bin/assets/ licences
openmetaverse_data/ (61 files)
Contents: avatar_lad.xml, avatar_skeleton.xml, and 59 TGA texture files
(avatar baking textures: skin, hair, clothing alphas, bump maps).
Origin: These files come from the Linden Lab Second Life viewer. They were bundled with the OpenMetaverse / libsecondlife library.
Licence status:
- The SL viewer artwork was released under CC-BY-SA 3.0 (see
ThirdPartyLicenses/DefaultTerrain.txtwhich contains the Linden artwork notice). - The XML data files (
avatar_lad.xml,avatar_skeleton.xml) are structural data from the viewer source, covered by the viewer's LGPL 2.1. - No explicit licence file exists in the
openmetaverse_data/directory.
Disposition:
- avatar_lad.xml, avatar_skeleton.xml: LGPL 2.1, GPLv3-compatible. Use Aurora Viewer's copies which are properly attributed under GPL-3.0-or-later.
- TGA textures (baking): CC-BY-SA 3.0. NOT GPLv3-compatible (only CC-BY-SA 4.0 has the one-way GPL compatibility provision). Do not bundle in Welkin. The server does not need these; they are viewer-side baking templates.
bin/assets/ (default asset library)
The asset library contains multiple asset sets loaded at server startup:
| Asset set | Contents | File count | Licence status | Disposition |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| AnimationsAssetSet | Avatar animation .dat files | ~85 | Unknown: no licence marker; likely Linden viewer content | Do not redistribute |
| Avatar | Avatar appearance data | Small | Likely OpenSim-created | Investigate |
| BodyPartsAssetSet | Body part definitions | Small | OpenSim-created (BSD-3-Clause) | May reuse |
| ClothingAssetSet | Clothing definitions | Small | OpenSim-created (BSD-3-Clause) | May reuse |
| CollisionSoundsAssetSet | Collision .ogg sounds | ~57 | Freesound.org credits; individual licences vary (CC0, CC-BY, possibly CC-BY-NC) | Audit individually; CC-BY-NC is NOT compatible |
| GesturesAssetSet | Gesture definitions | Small | OpenSim-created | May reuse |
| LandmarksAssetSet | Default landmarks | Small | OpenSim-created | Not needed |
| MaterialsAssetSet | Material definitions | Small | OpenSim-created | May reuse |
| MyAssetSet | User template assets | Small | OpenSim-created | May reuse |
| NotecardsAssetSet | Notecards | Small | OpenSim-created | May reuse |
| ObjectsAssetSet | Default objects | Small | OpenSim-created | May reuse |
| PhotosAssetSet | Photos | Small | Unknown | Investigate |
| ScriptsAssetSet | LSL scripts | Small | OpenSim-created (BSD-3-Clause) | May port |
| SettingsAssetSet | Environment settings | Small | OpenSim-created | May reuse |
| SoundsAssetSet | System sounds | Small | Unknown origin; may be Linden | Investigate |
| TexturesAssetSet | Default textures (.jp2) | ~155 | Mixed: some OpenSim-created, some Linden CC-BY-SA 3.0 | Audit individually |
Key finding: bin/data/LICENSE-README-IMPORTANT.txt explicitly warns:
"Not all of the files in this directory are licensed under the BSD license. Some of these files come with the Second Life viewer and are considered licensed under a Creative Commons License."
avataranimations.xml: CC-BY-SA 2.5
Disposition for Rust port: The server can start without a default asset library (grids import their own). Ship no default asset library initially. If one is needed later, build it from confirmed-licensed content only.
2.4 Warp3D and remaining unclassified DLLs
Warp3D
| Item | Detail |
|---|---|
| Binary | bin/Warp3D.dll (73 KB) |
| Source in tree | None. Only consumer code in OpenSim/Region/CoreModules/World/Warp3DMap/ |
| ThirdPartyLicenses entry | None |
| Usage | Server-side map tile rendering (software rasterizer) |
| Origin | Believed to be from the Avination/OpenSim fork; original Warp3D is a Java software renderer by Peter Walser. The Java version was released under a non-commercial restriction. |
| Licence | UNKNOWN / PRESUMED RESTRICTIVE. No licence file ships with the DLL, no header in the consuming C# code, and the original Java Warp3D had a non-commercial clause. |
| Disposition | Not needed. The Rust server does not render map tiles itself. If map tile generation is needed later, reimplement with tiny-skia (MIT/Apache-2.0) or delegate to the viewer. |
Remaining unclassified DLLs
| DLL | Investigation | Licence | Disposition |
|---|---|---|---|
| netcd.dll (23 KB) | etcd client for the EtcdMonitoringModule (optional module) | No licence file in tree; likely MIT or Apache-2.0 (common for etcd clients) | Dropped; etcd monitoring not in scope |
| Tools.dll (162 KB) | OpenSimulator build/packaging tools | BSD-3-Clause (part of OpenSim) | Dropped; Cargo replaces it |
| LukeSkywalker.IPNetwork.dll (18 KB) | IP address/subnet calculation library | Apache-2.0 (NuGet page) | Dropped; ipnetwork2 or std::net |
| ZstdNet.dll (29 KB) | .NET wrapper for Zstandard | BSD-3-Clause | Dropped; zstd crate if needed |
| libzstd.dll (581 KB) | Zstandard native library | BSD-3-Clause (Facebook/Meta) | Dropped; zstd crate if needed |
All remaining DLLs are now classified. No unidentified binaries remain.
2.5 JPEG 2000 evaluation
Current state
JPEG 2000 (J2K) is the mandatory texture format in the Second Life protocol.
Every texture asset is stored and transmitted as a .jp2 file.
In the C# tree: Two implementations exist:
CSJ2K.dll: Pure C# port of JJ2000. Custom licence with a field-of-use clause -- not clearly open-source.libopenjpeg-dotnet(native, in lib64/): C wrapper around OpenJPEG. BSD-2-Clause. This is the one actually used at runtime.
In Aurora Viewer: The aurora-assets crate depends on openjpeg-sys
(version 1.0.12), which is a Rust -sys binding to the C OpenJPEG library.
Licence: BSD-2-Clause. This is compiled from C source via cc build
dependency.
In Welkin currently: aurora-assets is declared as a workspace
dependency in the root Cargo.toml but is not actually used by any crate
(no aurora-assets in any crate-level Cargo.toml [dependencies]).
However, it appears in Cargo.lock, meaning it is resolved. The openjpeg-sys
dependency comes transitively through aurora-assets.
Pure Rust alternatives
| Crate | Status | Notes |
|---|---|---|
jpeg2000 (crates.io) | Also wraps OpenJPEG via -sys | Not pure Rust; same C dependency |
jxl-oxide | JPEG XL, not JPEG 2000 | Wrong format |
| No pure Rust J2K decoder | Does not exist as of 2026-11 | JPEG 2000 is complex (DWT + arithmetic coding + rate-distortion); no one has written a full pure-Rust implementation |
Recommendation
- Continue using openjpeg-sys via aurora-assets. BSD-2-Clause is LGPL-3.0-compatible. The C library is mature, fast, and well-tested.
- Accept the C dependency. A pure Rust JPEG 2000 decoder does not exist and would be a massive undertaking (~50k lines of complex signal processing).
- If avoiding C FFI becomes a goal, the only option is to transcode textures to PNG/KTX2 at ingest and serve a non-J2K format, which would break viewer compatibility.
- When Welkin actually needs J2K decode/encode (texture upload handling,
map tile generation), add
aurora-assetsoropenjpeg-sysdirectly as a dependency to the relevant crate.
2.6 Aurora's [patch.crates-io] section
The Aurora workspace Cargo.toml (at commit 3d523b14) contains:
[patch.crates-io]
naga = { git = "https://github.com/Aurora-Viewer/wgpu", rev = "3bad1916..." }
naga-types = { git = "https://github.com/Aurora-Viewer/wgpu", rev = "3bad1916..." }
wgpu = { git = "https://github.com/Aurora-Viewer/wgpu", rev = "3bad1916..." }
wgpu-core = { git = "https://github.com/Aurora-Viewer/wgpu", rev = "3bad1916..." }
wgpu-core-deps-apple = { ... }
wgpu-core-deps-emscripten = { ... }
wgpu-core-deps-wasm = { ... }
wgpu-core-deps-windows-linux-android = { ... }
wgpu-hal = { git = "https://github.com/Aurora-Viewer/wgpu", rev = "3bad1916..." }
wgpu-naga-bridge = { ... }
wgpu-types = { git = "https://github.com/Aurora-Viewer/wgpu", rev = "3bad1916..." }
What these patches do
All 11 patches replace upstream wgpu 30.0.1 crates with Aurora's fork
(Aurora-Viewer/wgpu, branch aurora/v30.0.1-empty-pool). The fork carries
a single 11-line fix for Intel 6th-9th gen iGPU Vulkan drivers that crash on
an empty descriptor pool (gfx-rs/wgpu#10124, Aurora #1302).
Impact on Welkin
None. These patches are irrelevant for several reasons:
-
Welkin does not depend on wgpu. It is a server project; GPU rendering is not in scope. Confirmed:
wgpuandnagado not appear in Welkin'sCargo.lock. -
[patch.crates-io]does not propagate through git dependencies. When Cargo resolves agitdependency (as Welkin uses for Aurora crates), it resolves only the crates in that git repo that the consumer actually depends on. The workspace-level[patch]section of the dependency'sCargo.tomlis ignored by the consumer. Only patches declared in the consumer's own workspaceCargo.tomlapply. -
The Aurora crates Welkin uses (
aurora-llsd,aurora-msg,aurora-prim,aurora-net,aurora-assets) do not depend on wgpu. The wgpu dependency comes fromaurora-renderandaurora-viewer, which Welkin does not pull in.
No action needed. The patches do not affect Welkin's build, its dependency tree, or its licence obligations.
GPLv3 compatibility summary
Licences confirmed GPLv3-compatible: MIT, BSD-2-Clause, BSD-3-Clause, Apache-2.0, ISC, zlib, PostgreSQL licence (Npgsql), SIL OFL 1.1 (fonts), CC0 1.0, LGPL-2.1-or-later.
Licences NOT GPLv3-compatible or uncertain:
- Ms-PL (BclExtras, DotNetZip, SmartThreadPool): FSF considers GPL-incompatible. All dropped.
- MPL-1.1 (GTCache): Not GPL-compatible on its own. Dropped.
- CC-BY-SA 3.0 (viewer artwork, default terrain): Only 4.0 is one-way GPLv3-compatible. Do not include 3.0 content.
- CC-BY-SA 2.5 (avataranimations.xml): Same issue. Do not include.
- Custom JJ2000 (CSJ2K): Field-of-use restriction. Dropped; replaced by openjpeg.
- "Used with permission" (CSCompilerTools): Not an open-source licence. Dropped.
- GPLv2 + FLOSS exception (MySQL Connector): Compatible only via the exception. Dropped; replaced by sqlx.
- Warp3D: Unknown / presumed restrictive. Dropped.
Naming and trademarks
- "Second Life" is a registered trademark of Linden Research, Inc. Use only in factual references to the platform or protocol.
- "OpenSimulator" names the upstream project from which this port derives. No endorsement by the OpenSimulator project is implied.
- "Aurora Viewer" and the Aurora logo are trademarks. Not used for this project or its binaries.
- Binary names:
welkin-robust,welkin-region. Theopensim-prefix identifies compatibility, not affiliation. - LSL (Linden Scripting Language) is a descriptive term used by multiple projects. No trademark issue identified.
Recommendations
- Run
cargo deny checkin CI. The workspacedeny.tomlenforces the licence allow-list and checks the RustSec advisory database. Add it to the build pipeline. - Do not ship a default asset library. The C# tree's assets have mixed and unverified provenance. Let grid operators import their own. If a default library is needed later, build it from scratch with confirmed-licensed content only.
- Keep openjpeg-sys. No pure Rust JPEG 2000 implementation exists. The BSD-2-Clause C library is mature and GPLv3-compatible. Accept the C FFI dependency.
- Do not include CC-BY-SA 3.0 content. Only CC-BY-SA 4.0 has the one-way GPLv3 compatibility provision. This rules out Linden Lab viewer artwork and the default terrain texture.
- Audit collision sounds individually before shipping any. The Freesound.org sourced sounds may include CC-BY-NC, which is GPL-incompatible.
- Pin Aurora Viewer crates to a reviewed commit. Currently pinned at
3d523b14. Re-audit when updating the pin. - Generate new default textures (terrain, avatar defaults) rather than porting the existing ones with unclear provenance.
Open items
- bin/assets individual texture mapping: Textures in TexturesAssetSet are not individually mapped to their licence source. If we ship a default asset library, each texture needs a confirmed licence.
- CollisionSounds licences: Freesound.org sources need individual licence verification (CC0, CC-BY, or CC-BY-NC -- the last is NOT compatible).
- Default library strategy: The C# default library has mixed provenance. Options: (a) ship no default library and let grids import their own, (b) build a new library from confirmed-licensed content, (c) audit each asset individually.
- netcd.dll licence: No licence file found. Low priority (module dropped).
- Warp3D original licence: If ever needed, would require sourcing clean implementation. Current plan: not needed for server.